Top-Grossing Movies That Never Hit #1, the Top 5, or Top 10

Data as of May 8, 1:56 PDT
Rank Release Total Gross Top Rank Overall Rank Year Distributor
1Mr. Bones$2,730,21110682001-
2The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe$2,521,4356902005-
3Madagascar$2,285,74691142005-
4The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring$1,874,42681882001-
5Mission: Impossible - Dead Reckoning Part One$1,728,715122172023Paramount Pictures International
6Garfield: The Movie$1,553,02862612004-
7I, Robot$1,417,163103062004-
8Wild Hogs$1,374,51063292007Buena Vista International
9Enchanted$1,350,58563432007Ster-Kinekor Pictures
10Music and Lyrics$1,145,784124252007Warner Bros.
11Rumor Has It...$1,098,03974542005-
12The Pursuit of Happyness$1,040,577154872007Sony Pictures Releasing
13Doubt$772,288146662009Ster-Kinekor Pictures
14Barnyard$738,751216942007United International Pictures
15Dungeons & Dragons: Honor Among Thieves$717,574197162023Paramount Pictures International
16The Mechanic$658,26877762011-
17Last Vegas$641,72867982013NuMetro Distribution
18Because I Said So$632,172108082007NuMetro Distribution
19A Cinderella Story$616,69788242004-
20Fahrenheit 9/11$573,62698912004-
21Nanny McPhee Returns$561,89869032010United International Pictures
22Into the Blue$554,01179132005-
23Silver Linings Playbook$551,90089202012Ster-Kinekor Pictures
24The Brothers Grimm$546,86089262006-
25Hoofmeisie$545,32879322011Ster-Kinekor Pictures
26Lion$530,60569522017Ster-Kinekor Pictures
27Footloose
2011 Re-release
$528,89569532012United International Pictures
28Dreamgirls$483,565201,0082007United International Pictures
29Walk the Line$471,28991,0212006-
30We Own the Night$466,83871,0272008United International Pictures
31The Secret of the Gods$453,21561,0562012Ster-Kinekor Pictures
32The Perfect Match$440,82261,0772016NuMetro Distribution
33The Iron Lady$436,60561,0812012NuMetro Distribution
34Broken Flowers$435,453101,0832005-
35Mao's Last Dancer$428,84271,0922010NuMetro Distribution
36Hall Pass$424,45061,0962011NuMetro Distribution
37The Best of Me$423,67871,0992014Times Media Films
38Knysna$421,07261,1032014Ster-Kinekor Pictures
39Hacksaw Ridge$420,09171,1052016African Entertainment Distributors
40Ellen: The Ellen Pakkies Story$416,83561,1122018Ster-Kinekor Pictures
41The Town$414,41761,1172010NuMetro Distribution
42Brüno$410,92761,1292009United International Pictures
43Wall Street: Money Never Sleeps$409,57161,131201020th Century Fox International
44The Hundred-Foot Journey$407,90061,1362014Times Media Films
45Flight$407,46561,1372013United International Pictures
46Quartet$406,96161,1382013Ster-Kinekor Pictures
47Monte Carlo$394,94161,1582011NuMetro Distribution
48You Again$394,70871,1592010Ster-Kinekor Pictures
49Into the Woods$394,03561,1622015Ster-Kinekor Pictures
50The Shack$389,84861,1682017Times Media Films
51Jumping the Broom$381,65371,1842011Ster-Kinekor Pictures
52My Life in Ruins$376,05861,1952009Ster-Kinekor Pictures
53Fighting with My Family$367,73261,2102019Times Media Films
54Open Water$362,65661,2232004-
55Salmon Fishing in the Yemen$359,40481,2322012NuMetro Distribution
56Knives Out$359,30561,2342019Ster-Kinekor Pictures
57The Nanny Diaries$344,09561,2702008Ster-Kinekor Pictures
58Wonder$340,830101,2772017Times Media Films
59Midnight in Paris$340,388101,2792011United International Pictures
60The Bank Job$339,92071,2832008United International Pictures
61The Reader$339,80291,2852009Ster-Kinekor Pictures
62Yogi Bear$339,38961,2862010NuMetro Distribution
63Behind Enemy Lines$337,81891,2912002-
64Pay the Ghost$335,603141,2972015-
65Poena Is Koning$335,24061,2982007Ster-Kinekor Pictures
66Serendipity$333,51961,3062002-
67Hollywood in My Huis$333,32761,3072015-
68Downton Abbey$329,65371,3132019United International Pictures
69Susters$326,41571,3212018Indigenous Film Distribution
70Stealth$325,39471,3232005-
71Homefront$319,32771,3302013-
72Colombiana$317,38261,3362011NuMetro Distribution
73The Hurt Locker$316,52571,3392010NuMetro Distribution
74Tashan$314,584181,3442008Ster-Kinekor Pictures
75Larry Crowne$314,30171,3452011NuMetro Distribution
76August Rush$309,373141,3562007NuMetro Distribution
77Angus Buchan's Ordinary People$308,74561,3612012Ster-Kinekor Pictures
78Babel$307,274161,3632007United International Pictures
79The Kite Runner$307,02181,3652008United International Pictures
80Paradise Stop$303,70271,3692011-
81The Help$302,07781,3722011Ster-Kinekor Pictures
82Vuil Wasgoed$300,63281,3782017Ster-Kinekor Pictures
83Are We Done Yet?$299,82861,3822007Sony Pictures Releasing
84Broken Promises 4-Ever$296,95661,3852018Indigenous Film Distribution
85Paranormal Activity$296,60081,3862009-
86Happily N'Ever After$296,13681,3872007United International Pictures
8721 & Over$295,74471,3902013NuMetro Distribution
88Gran Torino$295,57461,3912009NuMetro Distribution
89The Reef$293,93071,3952007NuMetro Distribution
90Dominee Tienie$290,81261,4062019Indigenous Film Distribution
91Kidnap$290,21771,4092017Ster-Kinekor Pictures
92Green Zone
2010 Re-release
$289,70261,4102010United International Pictures
93Fired Up!$286,23561,4212009Ster-Kinekor Pictures
94Losing Lerato$282,79181,4292019Indigenous Film Distribution
95Going the Distance$279,85461,4382010-
96Looper$279,16861,4402012Ster-Kinekor Pictures
97Hidden Figures$277,22171,442201720th Century Fox International
98The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo$276,71781,4442010NuMetro Distribution
99The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy$275,58081,4472005-
100A United Kingdom$274,98391,4492016Video Vision
10130 Days of Night$273,26261,4542007United International Pictures
102Sisters$271,36171,4582016-
103Make It Happen$271,10161,4592008United International Pictures
104My Name Is Khan$270,69861,4612010-
105The Impossible$270,45091,4622013NuMetro Distribution
106Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Mutant Mayhem$270,049241,4632023Universal Pictures International (UPI)
107A Quiet Place$269,75971,4642018United International Pictures
108Rainbow Skellums
Undated South Africa Release
$269,61961,465--
109Green Book$269,23571,4662019Times Media Films
110Van Wilder: The Rise of Taj$267,286211,4742007United International Pictures
111LOL$266,51771,4772012Ster-Kinekor Pictures
112One Day$265,47181,4822011Ster-Kinekor Pictures
113Almost Christmas$265,40761,4832016United International Pictures
114Aliens vs. Predator: Requiem$264,562131,4862008NuMetro Distribution
115Fighting$261,40861,4972009United International Pictures
116Yesterday$258,94471,5012019United International Pictures
117A Thousand Words$258,89181,5022012NuMetro Distribution
118Vaselinetjie$258,77761,5052017Ster-Kinekor Pictures
119Jennifer's Body$256,77961,508--
120From Paris with Love$256,18161,5102010-
121It's a Boy Girl Thing$255,495131,5122007NuMetro Distribution
122The Grand Budapest Hotel$254,86381,5142014Times Media Films
123The House$253,52871,5182017Times Media Films
124Diary of a Wimpy Kid: Dog Days$251,654121,5222012NuMetro Distribution
125'n Pawpaw Vir My Darling$251,38961,5242016-
126No Good Deed$250,10881,5282014Ster-Kinekor Pictures
127Everything, Everything$249,40371,5302017Times Media Films
128Jane Eyre$248,37991,5322011Ster-Kinekor Pictures
129So Undercover$247,06761,5362013NuMetro Distribution
130Rendition$246,94771,5382007NuMetro Distribution
131Paranormal Activity 2$246,35481,5392010United International Pictures
132The Five-Year Engagement$246,16571,5402012United International Pictures
133Noem My Skollie: Call Me Thief$243,897101,5472016Ster-Kinekor Pictures
134Konfetti$241,79161,5552014United International Pictures
135Open Season 2$240,75971,5602008-
136Machine Gun Preacher$240,13271,5612012NuMetro Distribution
137Baggage Claim$238,41161,5642013NuMetro Distribution
138Rock of Ages$237,91871,5662012NuMetro Distribution
139For Colored Girls$234,63371,5712011NuMetro Distribution
140Remember Me$234,50461,5722010NuMetro Distribution
141Dis Koue Kos, Skat$232,18381,5782016Times Media Films
142The Book Thief$229,77661,5892014NuMetro Distribution
143Us$229,38861,5902019United International Pictures
144Kalushi: The Story of Solomon Mahlangu$228,86561,5912017Times Media Films
145The Concert$228,835121,5922011United International Pictures
146Overdrive$227,371111,5952017African Entertainment Distributors
14712 Strong$226,91171,5972018Times Media Films
148No Country for Old Men$226,07571,6022008United International Pictures
149The Man$225,48681,6032005NuMetro Distribution
150The International$225,44771,6042009Ster-Kinekor Pictures
151The Monuments Men$224,38861,6092014NuMetro Distribution
152Lien se Lankstaanskoene$222,20961,6152013NuMetro Distribution
153Pride and Glory$222,07761,6172009NuMetro Distribution
154Astro Boy$221,26461,618--
155Disturbia$220,95071,6212007United International Pictures
156Baby Mamas$220,06161,6242018Ster-Kinekor Pictures
157The Skeleton Key$217,55661,6342005-
158The Post$217,24981,6352018Times Media Films
159Crank$216,21661,6402007Ster-Kinekor Pictures
160How to Steal 2 Million$215,791101,6422011Indigenous Film Distribution
161Vaatjie Sien sy Gat$214,74381,6432008Ster-Kinekor Pictures
162Bakgat! tot die mag 3$213,67071,6492013Ster-Kinekor Pictures
163Don 2$212,97861,6502011NuMetro Distribution
164Fiela's Child$212,50471,6512019Ster-Kinekor Pictures
165Mortal Engines$212,41071,6522018United International Pictures
166Mr. Brooks$212,34271,6542007NuMetro Distribution
167The Theory of Everything$212,18491,6552015United International Pictures
168Changeling$210,66361,6612009United International Pictures
169The Counselor$209,66081,6662013NuMetro Distribution
170Getroud met Rugby: Die Onvertelde Storie$208,53171,6682011Ster-Kinekor Pictures
171Long Shot$208,38461,6692019Times Media Films
172Thys & Trix$207,92961,6712018Ster-Kinekor Pictures
173The Messengers$207,69171,6722007NuMetro Distribution
174A Perfect Getaway$207,29891,6732010-
175The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society$206,11391,6772018Times Media Films
176Jou Romeo$206,11281,6782016Ster-Kinekor Pictures
177Coraline$206,09171,6792009United International Pictures
178The Secret Life of Bees$205,30461,6832009NuMetro Distribution
179Vicky Cristina Barcelona$205,273101,6842009United International Pictures
180Paranormal Activity 3$204,91261,6862011United International Pictures
181Last Chance Harvey$204,44771,689--
182Project X$204,22781,6912012NuMetro Distribution
183A Monster in Paris$203,26981,6932012NuMetro Distribution
184Arrival$203,15871,6942016Sony Pictures Releasing
185Hit and Run$200,93661,7022012NuMetro Distribution
186This Christmas$200,685211,7032007Ster-Kinekor Pictures
187The History Boys$200,32591,704200720th Century Fox International
188True Grit$200,198121,7052011United International Pictures
189The Artist$199,78571,7082012Ster-Kinekor Pictures
190Beyond the River$199,40861,7102017Ster-Kinekor Pictures
191The Shallows$198,80161,7132016Sony Pictures Releasing
192Krotoa$198,31191,7142017Ster-Kinekor Pictures
193Gringo$197,80271,7192018Times Media Films
194Lincoln$197,74591,7202013NuMetro Distribution
195Hotel Mumbai$197,69671,7212019African Entertainment Distributors
196Tag$197,20471,7242018Times Media Films
197Daddy Day Camp$196,873111,7262007Ster-Kinekor Pictures
198The Fighter$195,76161,7322011Ster-Kinekor Pictures
199Nine$195,62781,7332010Sony Pictures Releasing
200An Education$195,624101,7342010United International Pictures