| Rank | Movie Title (click to view) | Studio | Total Gross / Theaters | Opening / Theaters | Open |
| 1 | Before the Devil Knows You're Dead | Think | $7,084,227 | 321 | $73,837 | 2 | 10/26/07 |
| 2 | The Aristocrats | Think | $6,377,461 | 234 | $243,796 | 4 | 7/29/05 |
| 3 | Spellbound (2003) | Think | $5,728,581 | 117 | $17,508 | 1 | 4/30/03 |
| 4 | The Gospel of John | Think | $4,069,090 | 113 | $98,363 | 14 | 9/26/03 |
| 5 | Then She Found Me | Think | $3,735,717 | 153 | $72,594 | 9 | 4/25/08 |
| 6 | Born Into Brothels | Think | $3,515,061 | 127 | $14,605 | 1 | 12/8/04 |
| 7 | Half Nelson | Think | $2,697,938 | 106 | $53,983 | 2 | 8/11/06 |
| 8 | Strangers with Candy | Think | $2,072,645 | 109 | $43,141 | 2 | 6/28/06 |
| 9 | Avenue Montaigne | Think | $2,044,858 | 52 | $29,377 | 2 | 2/16/07 |
| 10 | Shortbus | Think | $1,985,292 | 70 | $107,907 | 6 | 10/4/06 |
| 11 | The Dangerous Lives of Altar Boys | Think | $1,815,864 | 125 | $55,000 | 9 | 6/14/02 |
| 12 | The Story of the Weeping Camel | Think | $1,763,052 | 55 | $21,767 | 2 | 6/4/04 |
| 13 | Keeping Mum | Think | $1,619,466 | 79 | $27,112 | 2 | 9/15/06 |
| 14 | Murderball | Think | $1,531,154 | 97 | $57,286 | 8 | 7/8/05 |
| 15 | Festival Express | Think | $1,174,079 | 43 | $12,074 | 1 | 7/23/04 |
| 16 | In the Shadow of the Moon | Think | $1,134,358 | 104 | $38,281 | 4 | 9/7/07 |
| 17 | The Last Kiss | Think | $1,048,950 | 31 | $33,561 | 5 | 8/16/02 |
| 18 | Encounters at the End of the World | Think | $944,933 | 39 | $17,730 | 1 | 6/11/08 |
| 19 | Bright Young Things | Think | $933,637 | 92 | $46,926 | 3 | 8/20/04 |
| 20 | Where the Truth Lies | Think | $872,142 | 95 | $234,461 | 95 | 10/7/05 |
| 21 | The Ten | Think | $769,726 | 47 | $121,374 | 25 | 8/3/07 |
| 22 | The Assassination of Richard Nixon | Think | $708,776 | 59 | $37,547 | 5 | 12/29/04 |
| 23 | Going Upriver: The Long War of John Kerry | Think | $614,138 | 163 | $279,219 | 163 | 10/1/04 |
| 24 | Down in the Valley | Think | $568,932 | 28 | $22,806 | 3 | 5/5/06 |
| 25 | Time Out | Think | $448,542 | 22 | $31,439 | 9 | 3/29/02 |
| 26 | When Do We Eat? | Think | $431,513 | 48 | $134,006 | 48 | 4/7/06 |
| 27 | Primer | Think | $424,760 | 31 | $28,162 | 4 | 10/8/04 |
| 28 | The Mystic Masseur | Think | $399,110 | 36 | $18,550 | 2 | 5/3/02 |
| 29 | Still, We Believe: The Boston Red Sox Movie | Think | $396,803 | 54 | $91,388 | 17 | 5/7/04 |
| 30 | The Boys of Baraka | Think | $323,860 | 9 | $9,705 | 1 | 11/30/05 |
| 31 | The King | Think | $282,183 | 16 | $8,927 | 1 | 5/19/06 |
| 32 | Taxi to the Dark Side | Think | $274,661 | 20 | $10,930 | 2 | 1/18/08 |
| 33 | The TV Set | Think | $265,198 | 19 | $34,531 | 8 | 4/6/07 |
| 34 | My Brother Is an Only Child | Think | $255,620 | 14 | $9,357 | 1 | 3/28/08 |
| 35 | Gerry | Think | $254,683 | 15 | $26,285 | 2 | 2/14/03 |
| 36 | Kontroll | Think | $237,183 | 6 | $10,098 | 2 | 4/1/05 |
| 37 | Wilbur Wants to Kill Himself | Think | $235,294 | 16 | $13,747 | 2 | 3/12/04 |
| 38 | The Agronomist | Think | $226,189 | 21 | $30,855 | 7 | 4/23/04 |
| 39 | Bus 174 | Think | $217,201 | 5 | $8,625 | 1 | 10/8/03 |
| 40 | Mondovino | Think | $209,618 | 8 | $9,840 | 1 | 3/23/05 |
| 41 | The Untold Story of Emmett Louis Till | Think | $204,956 | 10 | $8,230 | 1 | 8/17/05 |
| 42 | Fateless | Think | $196,857 | 9 | $12,680 | 1 | 1/6/06 |
| 43 | The Heart of Me | Think | $196,067 | 11 | $21,956 | 5 | 6/13/03 |
| 44 | Protocols of Zion | Think | $178,875 | 10 | $21,733 | 4 | 10/21/05 |
| 45 | Awesome: I F%!#in' Shot That | Think | $162,538 | 180 | $18,074 | 18 | 3/31/06 |
| 46 | Nanking | Think | $161,182 | 10 | $6,316 | 1 | 12/12/07 |
| 47 | 5x2 | Think | $128,752 | 5 | $15,667 | 2 | 6/10/05 |
| 48 | The Wendell Baker Story | Think | $127,414 | 17 | $48,120 | 17 | 5/18/07 |
| 49 | Love, Sex and Eating the Bones | Think | $116,869 | 8 | $32,648 | 8 | 3/5/04 |
| 50 | War/Dance | Think | $115,210 | 10 | $15,471 | 3 | 11/9/07 |
| 51 | World Traveler | Think | $103,863 | 19 | $16,072 | 6 | 4/19/02 |
| 52 | Self-Medicated | Think | $100,610 | 16 | $45,871 | 16 | 8/31/07 |
| 53 | 10 Items or Less | Think | $83,291 | 15 | $35,929 | 15 | 12/1/06 |
| 54 | The Walker | Think | $79,698 | 14 | $16,525 | 3 | 12/7/07 |
| 55 | Zoo | Think | $69,770 | 5 | $7,811 | 1 | 4/25/07 |
| 56 | Stuck | Think | $67,505 | 16 | $8,844 | 2 | 5/30/08 |
| 57 | Tideland | Think | $66,453 | 9 | $7,276 | 1 | 10/13/06 |
| 58 | Roman Polanski: Wanted and Desired | Think | $59,192 | 9 | $4,613 | 1 | 7/11/08 |
| 59 | 10th & Wolf | Think | $54,702 | 6 | $20,774 | 6 | 8/18/06 |
| 60 | Ghosts of Cite Soleil | Think | $48,752 | 3 | $7,100 | 1 | 6/27/07 |
| 61 | The Hip Hop Project | Think | $46,208 | 42 | $32,520 | 42 | 5/11/07 |
| 62 | The Zodiac | Think | $45,148 | 10 | $20,578 | 10 | 3/17/06 |
| 63 | Candy | Think | $45,128 | 12 | $3,646 | 1 | 11/17/06 |
| 64 | Tell Them Who You Are | Think | $39,075 | 4 | $4,060 | 1 | 5/13/05 |
| 65 | The Event | Think | $35,554 | 18 | $19,206 | 18 | 10/3/03 |
| 66 | Loverboy | Think | $33,223 | 4 | $13,285 | 4 | 6/16/06 |
| 67 | The Tracey Fragments | Think | $32,645 | 4 | N/A | N/A | 5/9/08 |
| 68 | The Hottest State | Think | $31,216 | 5 | $8,545 | 3 | 8/24/07 |
| 69 | Teknolust | Think | $28,811 | 3 | $9,475 | 2 | 8/22/03 |
| 70 | Good | Think | $27,276 | 8 | $9,508 | 2 | 12/31/08 |
| 71 | The Air I Breathe | Think | $25,775 | 7 | $19,487 | 7 | 1/25/08 |
| 72 | Lake of Fire | Think | $25,317 | 9 | $2,559 | 1 | 10/3/07 |
| 73 | Off the Black | Think | $24,425 | 4 | $6,763 | 2 | 12/8/06 |
| 74 | F**k | Think | $22,359 | 5 | $5,299 | 2 | 11/10/06 |
| 75 | Three of Hearts | Think | $21,429 | 1 | $4,482 | 1 | 10/19/05 |
| 76 | Dallas 362 | Think | $21,108 | 2 | $2,831 | 1 | 4/1/05 |
| 77 | Noise | Think | $16,513 | 2 | $3,687 | 2 | 5/9/08 |
| 78 | The Last Mogul | Think | $16,469 | 2 | $4,965 | 1 | 6/24/05 |
| 79 | Genesis | Think | $16,413 | 1 | $4,891 | 1 | 5/27/05 |
| 80 | I Like Killing Flies | Think | $16,214 | 2 | $5,487 | 1 | 7/28/06 |
| 81 | Live Free or Die | Think | $13,836 | 5 | $8,875 | 5 | 3/30/07 |
| 82 | Love in the Time of Money | Think | $10,410 | 4 | $6,040 | 4 | 11/1/02 |
| 83 | Glastonbury | Think | $8,419 | 3 | $1,179 | 1 | 2/23/07 |
| 84 | Looking for Kitty | Think | $4,480 | 1 | $3,210 | 1 | 9/1/06 |
| 85 | Blood and Tears | Think | $4,364 | 1 | $2,201 | 1 | 6/15/07 |
| 86 | I Love Your Work | Think | $3,264 | 1 | $2,580 | 1 | 11/4/05 |
| 87 | 95 Miles to Go | Think | $3,195 | 2 | $2,203 | 2 | 4/7/06 |
| 88 | Funny Money | Think | $2,844 | 4 | $1,839 | 4 | 1/26/07 |
| 89 | The Big Question | Think | $2,248 | 3 | $466 | 1 | 3/17/06 |
| 90 | The Dog Problem | Think | $1,344 | 2 | $914 | 2 | 4/27/07 |
| 91 | The Trials of Darryl Hunt | Think | $1,217 | 2 | $619 | 2 | 6/15/07 |
| Summary of 91 Movies on Chart: |
| Totals: | $62,640,978 | - | - | - | - |
| Averages: | $688,362 | - | - | - | - |
 |