| Rank
| Title
| Lifetime Gross | Max Theaters | Opening | Open Th | Release Date | Distributor
|
|---|
| 1 | Bruce Almighty | $242,829,261 | 3,549 | $67,953,330 | 3,483 | May 23, 2003 | Universal Pictures |
| 2 | Evan Almighty | $100,462,298 | 3,636 | $31,192,615 | 3,604 | Jun 22, 2007 | Universal Pictures |
| 3 | Michael | $95,318,203 | 2,325 | $17,435,711 | 2,141 | Dec 25, 1996 | New Line Cinema |
| 4 | Heaven Can Wait | $81,640,278 | 540 | $3,652,486 | 540 | Jun 28, 1978 | Paramount Pictures |
| 5 | Down to Earth | $64,186,502 | 2,521 | $17,268,883 | 2,521 | Feb 16, 2001 | Paramount Pictures |
| 6 | The Preacher's Wife | $48,102,795 | 2,008 | $7,649,752 | 1,783 | Dec 13, 1996 | Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures |
| 7 | Oh, God! | $41,687,243 | 198 | $2,040,920 | 198 | Oct 7, 1977 | Warner Bros. |
| 8 | Bill & Ted's Bogus Journey | $38,037,513 | 1,649 | $10,241,268 | 1,620 | Jul 19, 1991 | Orion Pictures |
| 9 | Dogma | $30,652,890 | 1,292 | $8,669,945 | 1,269 | Nov 12, 1999 | Lionsgate Films |
| 10 | Two of a Kind | $23,646,952 | 1,278 | $3,344,942 | 1,244 | Dec 16, 1983 | Twentieth Century Fox |
| 11 | Oh, God! You Devil | $21,538,850 | 1,384 | $5,560,001 | 1,384 | Nov 9, 1984 | Warner Bros. |
| 12 | Life of Brian | $19,398,164 | 5 | $140,034 | 5 | Aug 17, 1979 | Warner Bros. |
| 13 | Defending Your Life | $16,371,128 | 715 | $92,622 | 3 | Mar 22, 1991 | Warner Bros. |
| 14 | Oh, God! Book II | $14,504,277 | 1,033 | $3,439,846 | 1,033 | Oct 3, 1980 | Warner Bros. |
| 15 | Wholly Moses! | $14,155,617 | 608 | $3,625,280 | 608 | Jun 13, 1980 | Columbia Pictures |
| 16 | Almost an Angel | $6,939,946 | 1,373 | $1,608,365 | 1,373 | Dec 22, 1990 | Paramount Pictures |
| 17 | The Heavenly Kid | $3,852,271 | 1,019 | $1,614,225 | 1,019 | Jul 26, 1985 | Orion Pictures |
| 18 | Date with an Angel | $1,988,962 | 843 | $816,062 | 843 | Nov 20, 1987 | De Laurentiis Entertainment Group (DEG) |
